Sunday, August 6, 2017

"Dunkirk"

After reading rave reviews, I went to see "Dunkirk". What struck me immediately was the soundtrack.  It's loud... as Dolby can be. Cover-your-ears loud.  Dunno maybe it's more the sudden contrast than the intensity. But sometimes it's like a firecracker going off next to you.

Dolby is sound's version of 3-D. But old-timey 3-D with those special glasses was fun. Seeing Dr. Evil's hypodermic needle leaping out of the screen was definitely both scary and cool. Best of all the needle didn't hurt.


An excess of sound on the other hand  can leave you battered and dazed. Fans may worship the high-decibel beat of a rock concert. But it can easily overwhelm and diminish  a more visual medium. You strain to hear dialogue for instance. Especially  British soldiers speaking the King's English hurriedly or amid background noise.

Aside from being sound-shocked, I really liked Dunkirk. It's an immersive film even without the Dolby enhancement. The film captures the panorama of this epic historical retreat without relying on sensory overload. A single silent image often speaks volumes. Eloquence without thunder. 

The images of war are there of course  - unsettling but not horrific. Aerial dogfights, strafing fire, bombs, dead and dying laying on the beach but no close-up's of blood or dismembered bodies. Edge-of-your-seat stuff  but never devolving into turn-your-eyes-away overload.

Nolan creates suspense by focusing on the terror and weariness of a retreating, beaten army. Yet woven into this grim tableau are small glimmers of courage and humanity and hope. Subtle and powerful.

One scene that particularly resonates is the rescue of a downed Brit pilot by one of the small evacuation boats racing to Dunkirk. On board,  the  pilot demands that they turn back and return to England.  Out of earshot of him, the boat owner's son is perplexed by this seeming cowardice. His father explains "He's shell-shocked, son. He may never be the same."

  
Later the pilot's bizarre behavior forces them to lock the door behind him below deck. At some point, he turns violent and causes an accident which seriously injures the boat owner's other son. On the return trip to England,  the pilot, unaware that the son has just died of the injury, asks "Will the lad be ok?". The surviving son hesitates a moment, then simply answers "Yes".  The father  gives his son a poignant glance of approval.

These are the kinds of scenes that stick with me and make the film so memorable. It's well worth seeing. But, if you're at all sound sensitive, you might want to wait and watch it online sans Dolby.  Otherwise, you may need to cover your ears a few times.

Wednesday, May 17, 2017

Confessions of a reformed "Burner"

Recently I read a blogger talking about the joys of being able to burn debris on his ten-acre property in a rural area.  I breathed a huge sigh of relief that I'm no longer subjected to such "joys".  Hosanna to Cape George  and its no-burn zone.

Ah, I must confess to being a "burner" though when I lived in Clallam county.  It was then I begin to learn there was  a "pyro" lurking in the recesses of every rural psyche.  It starts innocently. You start to enjoy, slowly begin to  relish, then can't live without the addictive satisfaction of watching  yard waste and various other debris go bye-bye without a dump fee.

Seeing flames lick higher and higher grips you too.  It stirs something primitive -  the joy that comes of warmth; or maybe it's buried memories of group hunts and cooking wild boar; or  sleeping well knowing  beasties won't jump you in the night.  Or  yule logs and pagan rites.  Or de-cluttering. Or vanquishing darkness.... 

Back then, I watched it work on a neighbor across from me who started burning occasionally.  Then regularly, once a week. Shifting winds choked me with smoke... even though it was acres away.  Sometimes pleasant odors but increasingly acrid... the smell of something industrial.  I could never catch what it was... even with powerful binoculars.  She/he had an advanced case.

Now, I admit almost succumbing to the devilish ways of this incipient "pyromania"  for a few seasons. Then angst over global warming and flying embers and a possible runaway fire started to poison my joy. The final straw: a neighbor came each time to ask if he could add his own debris "since you already have a fire going".  How could I really enjoy guilty pleasures if I was enabling others to go down this dark path...

Then, it came to me.. I had three acres... and  several groves of trees. Branches, trimmings,  the odd piece of furniture, a bit of construction debris could all be broken down. Mostly just composted under the trees. It blends in nicely, nearly invisibly, in three treed acres.  Above ground it becomes "yard art".

 
Once in a while it needed to be broken down and  buried  like my old porcelain toilet that needed a good "dirt nap".  Yep, I admit that too - gradually there were "buried bodies" all over my property. Out of sight but that's the natural order of things after all. And no global warming..


Now my evolution is complete. My pyromania is a distant memory. Here, in Cape George, I don't burn... ever. Wouldn't if I could. But I still sweep a few small branches under a "green carpet" of existing bushes.  Makes a good mulch. Avoids a dump fee. What's more viscerally satisfying than that...

Friday, April 14, 2017

"The Zookeeper's Wife"

I drove to Seattle a couple of weeks ago to see
"The Zookeeper's Wife" in its first run. After watching the addictive trailer at least a dozen times,  I needed to up my hit. Ferries and Seattle traffic seemed inconsequential.

It's a fascinating tale with a haunting music score that hooked me from the start. The trailer scenes deliver an emotional wallop of their own. For me, the most moving of them was a young Jewish boy innocently raising his arms to be lifted into a German transport train. As protagonist zookeeper Jan looks on at the train station, the camera captures his shock, sadness, and look of foreboding. It's a powerful, cinematic moment...as if he flashed on the horror about to unfold but couldn't yet grasp the enormity of what he had seen.

This film is based on the same named book by Diane Ackerman. It's the true story of Dr. Jan Zabinska, a zoologist, his wife Antonina, and their young son Rhys. They owned the Warsaw Zoo and lived in a villa on the zoo grounds. The film's opening scenes depict their idyllic seeming life just before the German invasion in 1939.


Almost too idyllic.  Antonina looks sweetly at her sleeping son with baby lions sleeping beside him in the bed; opens the zoo's gates to visitors; rides her bike with a young camel tagging along; plays with an elephant; and greets Jan on his rounds. Their love and special rapport with animals are evident and touching. She refers to the zoo's animals as "her treasured guests".


But the movie doesn't stoop to sentimentality.  And early scenes may only be jarring if you're expecting another kind of movie -- perhaps a darker, quicker plunge into the horrors of the Holocaust. In the case of "The Zookeeper's Wife", this brush with sweetness ends quickly enough anyway.

Germany invades Poland and bombs nearly destroy the zoo.  The occupation  begins and the outlook for the zoo deteriorates. Ominously,  Jews are segregated and forced into the ghetto. Mass transports to concentration camps accelerate until the ghetto's emptied and burned by the Germans.

Miraculously, German zookeeper  Lutz Heck, Hitler's chief zoologist, has offered to take some of their surviving animals to a zoo in Germany and return them post-war.  Jan and Antonina quickly agree.


However Lutz,  returning in officer's uniform with German troops, assumes control of the zoo, and, with food scarce, shoots many of the animals not selected for relocation. The young camel that follows Antonina each morning is a heartbreaking casualty.

To save what's left of the zoo, Antonina and Jan re-purpose it to raise hogs for German troops and make daily runs to the ghetto for food scraps to feed them. Risking their lives, Antonina and Jan start smuggling Jews out of the ghetto. Jan alludes to the danger: "you can be shot for giving them a glass of water". Antonina brushes aside the risk: "We have room. Bring as many as you can".

 
On their daily runs to the ghetto, they ingeniously hide  Jews under food scraps in the truck's hold. Once out of the ghetto, they keep them safely out of sight in the zoo's emptied underground cages. Most will be smuggled out of the country with forged papers.
 

They manage to enable their guests --almost 300 during the course of the war-- to live undetected until they reach safety. All under the nose of Lutz and his troops. Antonina even feigns affection for him at a critical moment to evade danger. He's infatuated with her and she uses it to their advantage even as his familiarity becomes a source of unrest for Jan.

Each night after German patrols leave for their barracks. Antonina signals an all-clear on the piano and then serves dinner to her "Jewish guests". It's a moving tableau of kindness in the midst of terror. 


She also cares for a young girl raped by two soldiers.  Slowly Antonina gains her trust. Sharing a love of animals and a cautionary reflection that "you can never know who your enemies are or who to trust", she gently initiates healing.
 

There may be a tendency to pigeonhole this as just another Holocaust movie with formulaic tropes of good vs. evil. It's not. No bullet-proof heroes. No comically simplistic villains.  It's as much about healing and affirming life as overcoming evil.  It's not a documentary of  Holocaust horrors or a one-note war thriller.
 
Lutz, for example, was a well known zoologist. He's painted as more of an opportunist than anything, not one who descended into madness and pure evil. In the end, although he threatens to, he won't allow rage over Antonina's betrayal to push him into murdering Rhys.
 
A contrasting movie is the recent award winning "Son of Saul". Set in the infamous Auschwitz concentration camp,  its horrific scenes were integral to the story of Saul. The violence and imagery weren't gratuitous.

But  "The Zookeeper's Wife",  in  war-ravaged Warsaw, is a much different and arguably an equally powerful movie. Here the starkest imagery wouldn't have been the most cinematic and would have overwhelmed the poignancy of its other themes. Yet "The Zookeeper's Wife", with well-written affecting scenes of courage, resilience, and love, will linger just as memorably.

Monday, February 20, 2017

Food Coop - Got Juice?

Ah, our beloved Food Coop. It's one of the holiest of shrines in Port Townsend.  I've been a member for many years. So, with great reluctance, I'm about to complain.  On the scale of world problems, not a major complaint of course. Call it nostalgia for the good 'ole days.

Frankly,  however, I'm disenchanted.  One of the hallmarks of the independent food coops has been the availability of fresh juice. Nope, not any more, at least, not in the Coop's case.  They began curtailing hours, finding various excuses to pull the juicer offline, and finally with no further engagement of the membership pulled the plug altogether. The suggestion was made to simplify the juice offerings, even to pre-package them early in the day to avoid busy hours as other markets do.  The Coop hasn't responded.

They've also been aggressively "red-dotting" products which aren't hot sellers and pulling them from the shelves. Those left bereft must then run the gauntlet of a "special order". And that is an exercise in total frustration from the arcane  "user unfriendly" online lookup/ ordering to the "in a hurry, gotta be somewhere else" look of those special order employees when a customer with a lost look appears. By the way, their antiquated online ordering means  in-store only. Try squinting at a computer screen from a noisy perch in the aisle.

Nearby, their vitamin section requires a contortionist  to first find items but also frequently to retrieve them from a kneeling/ sitting yogic stance. The Coop offers various, timeworn excuses - not enough space for example - but relatively simple fixes leap to mind. Slightly elevated shelves for instance. Again no action.


Still, the employees are friendly and helpful. It's a pleasant shopping environment generally. But so is the QFC supermarket down the street, Sadly, the Coop appears to be  slipping and its privileged position as the only "Whole Foods" style grocer in P.T. is starting to show. Its drift is toward more of a "supermarket" feel, with its relentless march toward expansion and profit at the expense of customer service.

Saturday, January 28, 2017

Political Correctness and "Redskins"

Not too long ago members of the S'Klallam tribe mounted a relentless campaign to dump a local school's  Redskins mascot. They attended public hearings, harangued, and blogged,  and bulldozed until the mascot and logo were expunged.  A wider jihad against the Washington Redskins NFL football team has gone on for years.

Good grief. I have to wonder what’s next. Perhaps, even names such as Braves and Indians will  be caught in the roundup of shamed usage.  They'll become demeaning stereotypes no longer fit for politically correct company.

Could pacifists one day find Fighting Irish too reminiscent of saloon brawling in which the Irish often figured prominently.  Or Vikings get the boot at some point... the horned Viking helmet logo scrapped. Just another too painful reminder of a darker era when marauding Vikings brought terror to neighbors' shores.

Studies show that Redskin is not used in a racist or disparaging way in today’s world and hasn’t been for generations. Search recent memory banks... can anyone point to a disparaging racist usage of the term in modern times... in media or film, on racist signs seen at marches, overheard in beer joints, written in police reports of hate crimes... anyone?  Even many tribes do not share the concern and haven't jumped on this rickety, bullying bandwagon. 

There's a funny scene In the movie 'The Outlaw Josey Wales' which depicts an era in which the words redskins and palefaces were likely used as racist insults. Both words are spoken  and the speaker quickly follows with “no offense” And, in each case, the one hearing responds “none taken”. Of course, in the movie, both speakers were on the same side fighting real villains. But the point is we can laugh because any racist subtext is long gone.

There are of course words that do have a pernicious linkage to racism and  are no longer used. But, just as Fighting Irish or the Vikings don’t evoke  opprobrium today,  Redskins should be given a pass. 

Certainly, it's absurd to think sports team monikers were designed with racist undertones. They're not even used by the garden variety racist today for heaven's sake.  Any lingering racist use of the term should just be seen as the weakness it is.

Political correctness has become a game of empowering the private rage of a few, no matter what the cost. In this case it's bullying under the guise of exorcising  ghosts long since vanished.  Maybe, the world’s real issues and problems are so daunting there’s a need to invent new ones out of pain or frustration. But that effort is misguided.

Wednesday, November 2, 2016

"The Boys in the Boat"

 Last Thursday I braved darkness and rain to hear Dan Brown speak about his book  "The Boys in the Boat" at Chimacum High School. A friend from L.A. had sent me the book, a non-fiction account of the U.W's men's rowing crew who won gold in the 1936 Berlin Olympics.

When I felt the book in my hand, a NY Times bestseller for two
years,  I thought, "Well, maybe
... but nowadays I'm not sure I have the patience to slog through a 400 page book.  Perhaps a few pages...".  I was still measuring the book's thickness between thumb and forefinger when I opened it...
  
Maybe you're thinking as I did: Hm, competitive rowing... no thanks!. Resist the thought. Take a look... just a few quick peeks.

That's how I started.... skimming paragraphs, looking for something to grab my attention. But once in, I was quickly hooked and kept doubling back savoring the beautiful, compelling prose.  My leap-around strategy made it a quick read too: delightful memories of earlier passages had me turning pages avidly looking for more. By the time I saw the notice that the author was speaking, there was no way I was going to miss it!

Much of the backstory is fascinating: details of Northwest and UW's rivalries in the hard-scrabble thirties,  the popularity of competitive rowing, Pocock's famed cedar boats, the events in Berlin. But the  setting  could have been any sport...  badminton,  horse shoes,  ice curling. It's the people themselves that hold you tight... hook, line, and sinker.

Joe Rantz is the central figure and one of the boys in the boat.  He was still a teenager when abandoned by his father and step-mother in the depths of the Depression. One day, battered by misfortune,  his father quietly took him aside and told him "We can't make it here, Joe... But, Son,"  he continued, "the thing of it is, Thula wants you to stay here. I'd stay with you but I can't...".  .

 In a shattering moment of poignancy,  he adds, "Look Son, if there's one thing I've figured out about life, it's if you want to be happy, you have to learn how to be happy on your own".  Joe watched them drive away forever. His brothers, visible in the car's back oval window,  cried "What about Joe?".

Left to fend for himself in their half-built farm house in Sequim, WA, Joe decided at that moment that even with friends "he would never let himself depend on them.. nor on his family, nor anyone else again, for his sense of who he was. He would survive, and he would do it on his own."  He was only 14. 

He stayed put in the farm house, harvested berries and mushrooms, poached fish, logged, resold liquor purloined from smugglers... and survived on his own.  It was only at his older brother Fred's urging a few years later that he finally left Sequim to join Fred and his family in Seattle. 

Once there Joe entered the U.W.;  worked part time jobs to pay tuition;  studied;  got married; and, somehow, along the way, found time to earn a place on U.W.'s rowing crew.  After returning from the Olympics,  he "slowed down" a bit to finish his chemical engineering degree and begin his career. He spent 36 years working at Boeing.
 

In 2007,  the last year of his life, his daughter met the author at their HOA meeting in Redmond. She approached Dan after the meeting and related details of her Dad's life and wondered if he'd like to meet her Dad to hear more.

Intrigued, Dan met with Joe who by this time had entered a hospice.
Dan recalls asking Joe if he could write about his life. "No," ,  Joe answered to a crestfallen Dan. "But,"   after a moment's pause, he continued, "you could write about the boat". 


The story of the "boat"  and what it meant to the crew  is the heart of this wonderful narrative.  There were nine young men in the crew. Young men from working class families in the middle of the Depression who took time out to do something extraordinary and then kept on living their lives with the same tenacity.  Several became engineers; one a gynecologist; others rose to business management ; and one put himself through law school... eventually arguing and winning a case before the U.S. Supreme Court.
 

The Depression hadn't stopped them.  They had held part-time jobs,  completed tough college coursework,  excelled at the brutally difficult training that is competitive rowing,  and now, unfazed by the ominous backdrop of events in Germany,  they were going to take the next step. At the Olympics, in Berlin.

The day of the race, the coach announced their strongest rower, Don Hume, was too ill to compete.  The others talked it over and told the coach:  we're not just nine guys in a boat; we're  a crew... he's vital to the rhythm of the boat. ... If you put him in the boat, Coach, we'll pull him across the line... he can just go along for the ride". The coach answered  "Go upstairs and get ready.", shouting after them: "And bring Hume along with you!"

Not only was a feverish Hume, sick for weeks, a major setback, they had been living in a poorly heated police barracks with only cold-water  showers. Nights brought noise from parading storm troopers; police cadets drilling;  military maneuvers rattling through the streets below; and raucous parties in nearby rooms. Then officials assigned them the toughest rowing lane too so they'd battle the wind and be unable to hear the starter's call.  

But it was too late to sabotage their mission or dampen their determination.  They were nine young men who had bonded.  Nine young men who prevailed against the world's best and remained lifelong friends.  Strong men who grew even stronger together. They were  the "Boys on the Boat".

Sunday, October 23, 2016

A Tale of "Locker Rooms"

Ah, Hillary's got a glow now. She's put away that racist, sexist, xenophobic, misogynistic, bully of an opponent; schooled him on "preparing to be President"; soared with a vision of American values; and, yes, like "her good friend Michelle", affirmed the nobility of "going high when they go low".

But, of course, this is politics and there is the need to make public an opponent's egregious lapses; to twist and shape every phrase; corral every stray word; and hammer each misstep into the collective consciousness. So naturally her oration gratuitously soars high with a few words about "The Tape".

It's not just locker room crudity, she clarifies for those who haven't seen and heard the tape dozens of times : "It's who he is".  The subtext is presumably he's a sexist, predatory evil-doer not to be trusted in office or anywhere else.

But, if we're to weigh what's said behind closed doors, what is the litmus test for fitness. How does crude or sexist or predatory or homicidal get weighed and measured when it's off the cuff. Here's Hillary on her own, unscripted, talking about another "evil-doer":


http://www.newsmax.com/TheWire/clinton-assange-wikileaks-drone/2016/10/04/id/751517/


In fairness, "they" are trying to spin this away suggesting that it's totally apocryphal, a pre-schooler's rumor mongering. I wonder... I really wonder.


But, if it haunts you that it might be true,  suggesting "Can't we just drone this guy",, ie, Julian Assange, is hardly suggestive of American values.

If she's President,  who else will be in her cross-hairs? Which locker room is the scarier?

Monday, October 17, 2016

Riding the WAVE of competition...

I've had WAVE Broadband, an Internet provider, for years. A bit pricey but not too bad. Then a few months ago  it happened: my mental "radar" seemed to be picking up a small increase in the bill .. "Nah", I reasoned. After all, there had been no notice of an increase from WAVE.

Within a few months, it happened again. Again no notice. It nagged at me...I looked up previous bills. Yep, it was higher. I called WAVE. It WAS an increase and "No, we don't always send out notices of increases".

That was annoying. What if it's a billing error in their favor instead of a stealth increase for instance... what am I supposed to do: trust them to catch it?  The seeds of discontent had been watered well before I  saw  a 3 year  $19.95 fixed price from Century Link.


I had endured Century Link's slower DSL offering years ago in their past life incarnation as Qwest. Other than despising their nearly unnavigable website, I had managed well even for full-time employment. So I called and switched back to DSL. Take that, WAVE! 

My glee was short-lived.  How easily I had crossed the threshold into what suddenly felt like a "third world country" as ISP's go. Rickety infrastructure , communication snafu's, and a slo-mo pace. Kinda like quick-sand but slower.

First there was a paperwork blizzard. I filled a folder with Century Link mail: welcomes, contract legalese, service instructions, etc. Duplicates at times too.  Then confusion about install dates. Two installers showed up on different days. There was a problem transferring my phone number.

After getting nowhere with an online chat, I picked up the phone. Ah, a friendly voice. I repeated my name, phone, and address multiple times - three to be exact - during the first shuttle session. All transfers were punctuated with long holds. I was regaled with virtues of CenturyLink's latest bundles, including trying to up-sell me on a faster speed.

The outsourced help line was friendly and their English was only barely accented. They chirped pleasantly through canned scripts. I only had to restate the problem a couple of times. After a couple more calls and slightly choppy seas,  my phone number had been "ported" to its new home.


Then the real trouble started.  During the first six weeks, there were two half hour outages.  Not power outages but slowdown's that were evidenced by frozen screens and a cursor "not moving at all".  Kinda like the old 300 BPS in the telephone modem dial-up days. You typed a key and were able to stand and walk around the room before the cursor was ready for the next keystroke.


Even with normalcy restored,  my daily news feed that usually took under thirty seconds or so routinely took several minutes now. Google mail frequently whined "Something's not right"  over slow transfer speeds. I called the "tech" line and it was "deja vu all over again".  Their expert told me  to re-try unplugging and restarting. Repeatedly.

Bottom line: I'm back with WAVE. They had wised up with an ad for a phone-internet bundle at $29.95 a month for a full year. So I lept for the phone.


Hah! I had successfully played the field. Ain't competition grand...


Tuesday, June 7, 2016

"Vote For" Signage



They're starting to sprout up...  like weeds in summer.  The signage for presidential candidates I mean. Ok, I'm guilty... I admit it. I put up two small, discreet "Vote Bernie" stickers of my own.

But the anointment of Hillary is clearly approaching. Kinda like a mudslide after a clear-cut. They're even  laying a guilt trip on Sanders for not  joining the cheering throngs in this historic moment - the first woman to be a major party candidate. 

Guilt evidently has become the new political weapon of choice. Tell me: did the much lampooned Madeleine Albright speech about  "a special place in hell for women who don't support Hillary"  make a comeback?  Silly me... I thought it was still good for a few laughs.

Speaking of guilt trips, Mr. Trump's supporters could just as easily whine about the  failure of Republicans to jump on a congratulatory band-wagon for "The Donald". To their immense credit,  many haven't. Some even refuse to wave as the band-wagon passes. Maybe, it's the thought of losing again... this time their lunch... if they climb aboard.

I think Mr Sanders' supporters view Clinton in much the same light. Instead of concentrating on issues, she hurled unconscionable smears at Bernie; refused to share a syllable of those little hundred grand honorariums for Wall Street speeches; ran her own  private servers in clear violation of policy; voted for war in Iraq over WMD; and now promises a "no fly" zone over Syria... yes sir, she'll show Obama and the rest of the boys 'n girls how it's done. Clearly she's a deep well of "foreign policy experience" and unquestionable trustworthiness. Honest as the day is long.

I think Bernie and his supporters fighting to the last is a good thing for the Party and the country.

Wednesday, April 20, 2016

The Danger of Clear-Cuts


The Saturday March 26 edition of the Seattle Times reports another disturbing case of trees being
clear-cut. Read the Times story here.

This one didn't happen in the jungles of Brazil; or Oso, WA; or a billionaire's private island... but on a full acre in the heart of Seattle.

One hundred fifty three trees, mostly big-leaf maples, were illegally cut in a West Seattle green belt and slide zone. But of course now there's an enhanced view of Seattle's skyline for a suspiciously near homeowner.

So a "round up the usual suspects" call went out. Alas it appears the "perp" still has a good chance of skating. Even sadder, there is a significantly increased threat of slides and property damage.

As Seattle's forestry manager points in the news article: "Trees provide wildlife habitat, combat air pollution and help stabilize slopes by managing surface water."

After decades of devastating slides and bluff erosion in Seattle and elsewhere, this should be a cautionary tale for every community, including Cape George.

But permits are required in Cape George to cut trees so there must be some level of due diligence, right? Not so much. Recently, Cape George's manager stated he couldn't recall  "ever denying a tree cutting request".

On Sunset Blvd for instance, we've seen trees on banks -- both on the waterfront and elsewhere -- cut with impunity. Trees are protected by Cape George covenants but that matters little if cutting them comes without a speed bump  from a manager who can't or won't say "no".


Worse, if someone's trees are ruining your damn view, you may be able to coax Cape George's manager, to issue a "hedge" violation. Then you'll likely hear the chains firing  up again... See here for details of a recent case on Sunset Blvd.

But back to concerns of the waterfront bluff erosion that's been worsening the last few years. Take a walk on the beach to see what's afoot... or awash. Watch your step. Lots of tree-fall will block your path. Overhead, some scarily leaning trees hang on by a thread.

Has there been any engagement on these issues by Cape George's Board, or the Environmental Committee?  What do experts recommend?  Are
replacement plantings even recommended when trees are cut? Will a few sprigs of ground cover mitigate the loss of a tree?

Another concerning incident. Not long ago, several mature trees on the hill by the waterfront park were cut down. You'll see them -- or what's left of them -- on Colman Dr. as it climbs past the park. The stumps provide a visual, if very ugly, reminder.

As I recall, there was no mention in the newsletter about why the trees were cut nor any report of a plan to mitigate water runoff on that very steep site. But why wasn't there a plan?

Within a season or so after the trees were cut there was a washout and damage to the park's entry road after a heavy rainstorm. Was this very clear risk of more water runoff and erosion not foreseen? Was the permit just rubber-stamped? Or do "climate deniers" simply claim that cutting trees on the adjacent hillside had no likely impact...

Sadly, it appears there's a corporate agenda in place. "Cut permits" are a joke. Tree-protecting clauses in Cape George's covenants are as well. They are either ignored or subverted to appease the agenda of those who demand views. If this looks like the rant of a conspiracy theorist, see more evidence here and here
.

At the very least, the Board should study and proactively inform the community about the risks. Add some recommendations for preserving bluffs in the official documents; publish regular tips in the
newsletter; toughen the permitting process.  Schedule or re-schedule a Cape George University talk by a geologist, arborist, etc.

Business as usual isn't sustainable.




A Tribute to Edmond Blau

It's nearly Passover and it reminds me that it's been just over a year, in Jan 2015, that Ed passed away. I'm not religious and know little about Passover. But I feel an affinity for it -- it's  suggestive of hope and resilience and safety.  And it fits Ed's life.

Some may remember him. He was a sturdy bear of a guy who lived here on Sunset Blvd for almost ten years. After I moved here, I often saw him walking rapidly up the street, always with a hat,  and with what seemed like a strong determination to be somewhere or find something. I wondered who he was...

I finally met him in the park one summer. Almost eighty then but certainly not looking frail, he had a backpack and asked if I knew where Beckett Point was.


I pointed down the beach. Inwardly I shuddered. It's about a five mile round trip hike and looked like an obstacle course of fallen trees due to bluff erosion.

He must have sensed my concern and suddenly we started to talk about other things. In a stream of consciousness kind of a way, he mentioned being Dutch. After hearing my Dutch surname, he spoke a little Dutch which I tried to echo to his amusement.

The Dutch it turns out are very sensitive about the pronunciation of their words. Ed explained they caught many German paratroopers dressed in stolen Dutch uniforms during the invasion because of the difficult hard "k" sound that Germans would mangle. They just couldn't get "Scheveningen" right. 


I tried to pronounce it. Nope!  Ed, with a slight smile , promised not to "turn me in".

He related he and his mother had been in hiding during the war. Not immediately after the invasion though. Most couldn't believe the horror to come. It came slowly at first then accelerated quickly. They endured horrific prejudice and a relentless set of decrees as the noose tightened. 


Signs forbidding Jews appeared overnight. Dismissals from jobs, confiscation of homes, cars, and eventually bicycles were next. Obligatory stars had to be worn on clothing. Then came arrests and call-ups for "relocation".  Two years after the invasion,  it was time to disappear.  Ed was nine years old.

An Uncle in the Dutch resistance helped them go underground in the nick of time. Mass deportations had begun. For three years until Canadian tanks rolled into Utrecht, they stayed hidden passing through a dozen or so safe houses in the process.

After the war,  they emigrated to Philadelphia. Ed went on to graduate Phi Beta Kappa from the University of Pennsylvania. He won a full scholarship to West Virginia University medical school. 


Ed had planned to become a psychiatrist. But he never attended West Virginia.  He had lost confidence that he could do well enough. Maybe  post-traumatic stress, common to Holocaust survivors, had set in and robbed him of what he wanted so badly.

He went to the West Coast, got an MSW from Berkeley. But, he never became a social worker either. Instead he was  a longshoreman in San Francisco and later L.A. for over thirty years. One who read the New York Times on his lunch hour. 

After retirement, he fled California, found Port Townsend, and relocated here.  He read, walked, worked out at the gym, and gave to others. A top contributor to Habitat For Humanity, he found their efforts inspirational. "It restores my faith in humanity", he told a news reporter.
 

Then just a few  short years ago Ed was diagnosed with Alzheimers. It crept in slowly. He forgot little things. Then one day in a panic, he couldn't remember where he parked his car.  Details of his life in hiding and buried pain were now locked away. 

But, he continued reading avidly, including the daily New York Times.  He continued to walk and work out.  A trainer at Evergreen Fitness was impressed with his strength and tough regimen even as his condition worsened. He still loved music. He smiled at jokes.

In a time where so much seems to be going wrong in the world, Ed's story still resonates. It's hard to imagine the constant fear, the enforced stillness, and isolation of his childhood. Yet  he didn't emerge embittered or reclusive. 


He didn't give in to the disease either. Even as he battled, he remained the cultured, erudite European gentleman who looked for the best in everyone .

I will always remember him as  a fighter, a strong "tough guy" with a heart of gold.  He was my friend. I miss him.

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Corporations and Cape George

I just finished reading the Cape George Board Meeting Agenda for Jan 14 2016. One item caught my attention:

     President Richard Hilfer and the Manager have developed
     a list of law firms that specialize in providing service
     to homeowner associations and will be developing a request
     for proposal letter to assist with selection of a new
     attorney for the corporation.

 

It's still weird to think of  Cape George as a corporation. Actually, it is and, for many, the word conjures up a soul-less, arrogant entity concerned only with profit, running roughshod over enemies and shareholders alike,  with imperious Boards and CEO's doing virtually anything they damn well feel like.

I guess you can blame it on the media. It's difficult to pick up a newspaper without seeing stories of corporations fined for civil and more often criminal misbehavior; corporate officers under investigation, indicted, dismissed, or retiring suddenly to "spend more time with family"; stockholders defrauded; employees exploited; whistle-blowers abused and unjustly fired.



You might feel that's unlikely to happen here in Cape George. We're a feel-good community. Friendly residents, plenty  of volunteerism, lectures, games, cookout's. No need to bother pretty little heads with details of HOA's, CCR's, corporate governance, ad nauseum.  No controversy in paradise, right?


But take a peep behind the scenes. As mentioned here and here, this Board has ignored covenants; openly championed a former Board member who was rebuffed by the 2003 Board in her attempt to force a resident's old-growth trees to be clear cut;  ignored advice from their recently retired attorney as well as multiple other lawyers; and then  recklessly reversed the 2003 Board's ruling.


The Board's tactics -- all very corporate like --  were to dodge  the  resident's questions, stonewall her requests, deny an appeal, and bank that she would quickly take down the offending "hedge" of old-growth trees. When she asked for relevant archive files, she was told that they were "missing" from the office. Very Nixon-esque.

Meanwhile, let fines are pile up and suggest, as the President did in a newsletter and in a letter to an atty, that the complainants had "offered to bear the cost of removing all the trees". He conveniently omits that the offer was contingent on clear-cutting all of them. 

Even the owner's compromise offer to fell a couple of  trees and "window and thin" others per the Building Rules was rejected out of hand. Only when the owner felled all but two of her old-growth trees, was  the Board's notion of "hedge" justice served. Tellingly, during the massacre, the Cape George manager was seen conferring with the former Board member a block away. 

The 2003 Board however had unanimously dismissed a "hedge" complaint against the same trees and cited the lack of "timeliness" and "damage to a member's property" as reasons. They certainly did not dismiss the complaint with "prejudice" to open the door for the current Board's ruling.

Why did previously exempted old-growth trees become fair game? Because, the current President overruled the Cape George atty's advice and declared "trees grow and change" which rendered the 2003 ruling magically invalid.  His  reversal creates an Alice-in-Wonderland kind of legal whimsy. That's why rogue corporations seem to spend so much time in court.  An atty. confessed he was totally "baffled" by the President's remark.
 

 In some murky backroom, the Board also arbitrarily and without notice to the community changed the interpretation of a "hedge" to be as little as "two trees with commingling foliage". To obfuscate when the changeover occurred, the Board President told concerned dissenters  that the two-tree-commingling rule had been in effect for "years". Cape George's manager then slipped and reminded him that the new interpretation had been in effect only a few months.

When subsequent letters of protest to the Board's actions were
mailed to the community, the President ratcheted up his response
by drafting a letter to a couple of dissenters.  "What status do you have to intervene in a matter between the Board and the owner on Sunset Blvd" the President demanded in his letter. Really? Sixteen residents and others with atty's opinions in hand, had no right to question his corporate wand of authority...

To send out a bullying letter is hardly good corporate governance.
This response from the President was sent only after letters of protest were mailed to most of Cape George and two and half months after the original petition was sent. That speaks for itself.

However, it's typical of the incivility and arrogance of both the
Board president and certainly the manager (undoubtedly at the Board's bidding) who then routinely ignored residents' letters and phone calls during "Tree-Gate". It's not much of a stretch to assume that happens frequently when opinions do not align with corporate agenda. Or more accurately, the current Board's.

One frequent tactic of the current Board is the patronizing deflection: "you don't know the full story"  or the President's imperious sarcasm: "You're entitled to your opinions but not your own facts". Of course, as it happens, he can't reveal what the facts were since it's a "legal" matter and only the anointed can hear them.  There's the sharp bang of a slamming corporate door again.
 

The Board's most reliable tactic however is to just ignore letters from fined residents or nuisance communications from dissenters. For instance, a proposal for an amendment to the Building Rules mailed to the Cape George manager wasn't even acknowledged. He's become an agent of the Board and mirrors their incivility when it suits him. I wonder how quickly he hit the email delete button...

The "usual suspects" also routinely fail to engage the community
or provide transparency on a range of issues. Pickleboard-Gate was discussed here for instance. There's not even a brief summary of what went on behind closed doors.  


Of course all these secret, weighty matters could be summarized with identifying  content redacted. Why not? The residents "in good standing" have a right to know what the Board is doing, when "interpretations" of Building Rules change suddenly; what the Board's atty advised;  why a decision was reversed after 12 years; what other trustees thought, or didn't think;  or whether all of them  simply wielded the rubber-stamp...

Where is it written that a corporation can't act more transparently;
engage residents in choosing a Pickleball court venue or decide how to define a hedge;  put divisive issues up for a vote; apprise residents of legal details in broad strokes so they can be informed about what's happening in the community; defend and explain Board actions; allow residents to provide feedback, and rate the quality of  their leadership. Even large, ruthless corporations make more of an attempt than they do here. I'm sure residents would pitch in to handle some of the details if the volunteer Board is overworked. I gladly will!
 

So "corporatism" is alive and well in Cape George. Will that change? Unlikely without more activism by residents here. The good news is that abuses by the current Board President and rubber-stamping trustees can be opposed in court. 

If you have been harmed by the Board's actions, please consider a small claims case if nothing else. Email if you like. I'll be glad to share atty's opinions on the tree issue for instance.

Sadly in my opinion, litigation may be the  only way to deal with
this Board's  intransigence, arrogance, and failure to listen. Consider also running for the Board or encourage someone who will if these issues bother you as much as they do many others.


There's reason for hope. Here're some encouraging signs that changes have happened or may be coming to a HOA near you.


From: 
https://en.wikipedia.or/wiki/Homeowner_association#Undemocratic

 

The AARP has recently voiced concern that homeowners associations pose a risk to the financial welfare of their members. They have proposed that a homeowners "Bill Of Rights" be adopted by all 50 states to protect seniors from rogue Homeowner Associations.

Certain states are pushing for more checks and balances in   
homeowner  associations. The North Carolina Planned  Community Act for example requires a due process hearing to be held before any homeowner may be fined for a covenant  violations It also limits the amount of the fines and sets other restrictions.
 

In California, any rule change made by the board is subject to a majority affirmation by the membership if only 5% of the membership demand a vote. This part of the civil code also ensures that any dissenting individual who seeks a director position must be fully represented to the membership and that all meetings be opened and agenda items publicized in advance.
 

The Supreme Court of Virginia has ruled that a HOAs power to fine residents is an unconstitutional delegation of police and judicial power.
 







Monday, November 23, 2015

Pickleball Controversy


I've been trying to gather more information about the pickleball court brouhaha.  No... I am not an agitator poking into every possible controversial issue to roil peace and harmony in Cape George. 

But, there is unquestionably a history of the
Board opting to make decisions in ways, that are secretive, heavy-handed, overreach covenants, tilt toward favoritism, and encourage favor-seeking.

For instance, the President used the August 2015 newsletter to openly champion a resident and former Board member who wanted a neighbor to clear-cut old growth trees targeted as a "hedge violation". Sadly, propelled by the current Board's absurd interpretation, the resident was compelled to cut all but two of the targeted trees to the ground. The Board's actions were in complete violation of our covenants and completely ignored the windowing and thinning suggested in the Building Rules.

Had the resident targeted by the Board's overreach lived in state, she would have taken the Board to court. Multiple atty's, including those of a prestigious law firm in Seattle, have examined our covenants and written strongly adverse opinions about the legality of the Board's actions. For more about the issue: see post here and another here.

But, back to the Pickleball controversy. If you linger around the mailboxes, you will notice that pickleballing can be loud. Very loud. Imagine you live in an adjacent home, say one on Cape George Rd. or those just above the court on Quinault Loop. You'd be mad as hell and demand a few answers.

As I understand it, there was no engagement of the community as a whole in the decision. No announcement with a clear plan of action. No statement of alternatives. Just one fine day, a crew breaks ground for a new pickleboard court.

Was there perhaps some lobbying behind the scenes by a few "select members" who enjoy the sport...say an ex-Board member or prominent volunteers for instance who feel a sense of entitlement. Totally baseless speculation you may argue... Besides who wants to play the "Grinch" on the issue of a wonderful, fun-filled pickleboard court...  

But the issue is not project worthiness but rather a lack of  community involvement. What other sites were studied? Impacts? Costs? Amenties? Would badminton or tennis have been favored over pickleball?

Noise travels well uphill so did anyone poll
neighbors, research decibel levels, solicit community suggestions, call for a vote, or
even briefly consider adequate bathroom access?

As it turned out, I understand there was a constant parade of pickleballers dancing into the Cape George office for bathroom breaks. Did the office administrator suddenly decide enough was enough. Whatever unfolded, several pickleball players were spotted taking leaks behind the barn until a resident's threat forced a port-a-potty rental.

Reasonably, I think, a few questions should be asked.  What other sites were considered? If not, why not?  Why wasn't the community permitted input... why not a vote?

Was the large open field adjacent to the clubhouse in the running?  After all, it would have been only a few yards to the clubhouse bathroom. There's even a bathroom accessible outside the clubhouse. Definitely more access to parking. And, arguably fewer would have been impacted by noise since the clubhouse site is more isolated from homes. 

Was there an "executive" decision made by our corporate-wannabe Board about the relative benefits to certain residents - both decision to build and choice of site. Another baseless speculation... well, maybe but when Boards go "dark" about decisions and imagine they have some kind of pseudo-corporate purview to do whatever they choose, then there will be dissension.

The pickleball court is an unfortunate example of what can happen when planning is poor or non-existent. Or, even if carefullly planned, nothing is made public. It's also what tends to happen when decisions are made by a Board which doesn't choose to engage the community; is especially opaque about even routine issues; holds numerous closed door meetings; and has no compunctions about dubious interpretations of the covenants and rules.

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

Coyotes vs. Cape George


A wildlife specialist spoke about coyotes at the latest Board meeting. It was a fascinating talk with some common sense suggestions for keeping pets safe, reducing attractants, and confronting coyote aggression.  A question and answer session followed.

I vaguely remember someone wondering if a "trap and relocate" effort would rid Cape George of this "dire" menace. The answer was "no". Other coyote families would move right in.


What struck me though was another resident who suggested shooting them. I thought at first she was probably joking. She wasn't. Not that I could detect anyway...

Her solution: shoot these opportunists who make an occasional meal of pet food left outdoors and are prime suspects in pet disappearances.


Yep, get out the shotgun and have at 'em. Except the use of firearms is prohibited in Cape George... Whew! The image of geriatrics shooting off shotguns at random hours still leaves me uneasy.
 

Coyotes can pose a danger admittedly...even to humans in rare cases. However, the level of anxiety here surprised me. Potentially, I suspect local cougars could be much more of a threat. Particularly to pets or small children. And on wooded trails even to a lame geriatric or two...

Cougars seem to be rarer, far more elusive, and less vocal though. They're also essential in controlling deer populations. So they are unlikely to rate a Cape George Board discussion item any time soon.

Then there are raccoons which are also known to devour pet food, drown dogs, hiss and snarl aggressively, transmit various diseases, and can cause nasty bites. But, they seem to get a pass too. I guess it pays to be a little less noisy at night!

The speaker covered the basics but here's a far more interesting take on coyotes. The bottom line is coyotes are resourceful creatures and an essential part of the ecosystem in keeping rodent and rabbit populations in check.


They're amazingly resilient too. If they can carve out a niche in big cities like L.A., the alarmists at Cape George don't have a prayer of stopping 'em.

Here's an excerpt of the actual article:

 I've studied coyotes for more than 35 years,
 and along with research and performed by my
 colleagues, we've discovered that talking
 about "the" coyote is misleading. The moment 
 one begins making rampant generalizations 
 they're proven wrong. For example, in some 
 areas coyotes live alone, in other locations
 they live with their mate, while in others
 they live in groups that resemble wolf packs 
 -- extended families of different 
 generations. In these packs there are 
 "aunts" and "uncles" who help to raise 
 youngsters. Coyotes are sometimes 
 territorial and sometimes not. In a 
 nutshell, coyotes are quintessential 
 opportunists who defy profiling as 
 individuals who predictably behave this way 
 or that. And, this is one reason why they 
 are so difficult to control. 

 Killing does not and never has worked. When 
 a space opens where a coyote had lived
 another individual simply moves in. Usually 
 the offending coyote is not identified. And 
 it is ethically indefensible to wantonly 
 go out and kill coyotes because they try to
 live among us, arrogant big-brained 
 invasive mammals who have redecorated the
 homes of coyotes and other animals and then
 conveniently decide that they have become
 "pests" when we don't want them around any
 longer. The Texas governor's utterly
 unacceptable actions come as more cities in
 the Denver and other metropolitan areas are
 realizing that the best way to address
 conflicts with coyotes is to examine our own
 behavior. Confrontations with coyotes can
 almost always be traced to irresponsible
 human actions including allowing dogs to run
 free off leash and feeding the coyotes,
 either intentionally or unintentionally. And,
 it's pretty easy to clean up all of these
 problems and coexist peacefully with coyotes.

Sunday, August 16, 2015

Letters to Cape George Board


Thanks to the Board, several letters supportive of the Covenants and preserving trees have been published.  They appeared under the August 11, 2015 "Events and Notices" information packet link on Cape George's website.

See the letters on pages 3-14 of the document by clicking here.


That member letters appeared - even buried deeply - is enough to hearten those concerned about the extreme definition of a "hedge" and the even more extreme remedies being applied for "hedge violations". For more about the issue, see earlier post by clicking here.

In his response to one of these letters, the Board President cites "Lakes at Mercer Island Homeowners Assn. v. Witrak". Briefly, that case involved a homeowner, who although denied a permit, went ahead and planted 12 huge Douglas Fir trees, each between 25 and 30 feet high.  She must have hired a forklift and worked in the dead of night to pull it off!


It was part of an ongoing dispute between the homeowner and the HOA. There was, however, a clear restriction written into the Mercer Island CCR's so her action was impermissible. The court naturally ruled in favor of the Mercer Island HOA. 

This case, however, doesn't remotely resemble what's happening in Cape George. The trees being targeted here are mature trees planted years ago - not ones illicitly planted to circumvent a clear restriction. Our covenants encourage planting vegetation; their language is protective of trees; and building rule 3.2 prescribes windowing and thinning to enhance views.


The Board's extreme actions are based on their interpretations -not of the Covenants- but of subsequent Rules and Regulations. An atty. here points out that "the Board cannot enforce by Rules and Regulations, what the Covenants protect". This is the legal equivalent of going the wrong way on a one-way street.

Moreover, the existing hedge remedies are absurd in specifying the same penalty for shrubs and trees. A shrub cut to 8 ft gets a "haircut"; a mature tree cut to 8 ft gets the "death penalty". The permitted alternative to strip "any two adjacent mature trees of commingling foliage" just equates to a "slower death". This is a clear violation of the language and intent of our Covenants and Rules.

Citing the Witrak case is once more an attempt to justify an extreme interpretation. However, the Witrak case is not on point nor are the facts similar to what's happened in Cape George. Multiple attorneys have pointed this out to the Board over the years. Their opinions are available to anyone interested.  


A "hedge" of 100 ft. trees on the Marquess of Landsdowne's Scottish estate doesn't justify an extreme definition either. Huge trees are not what is commonly intended by the word hedge.  And you certainly can't shoehorn this extreme definition into a Building Rule in an effort to get around the Covenants. Again in the opinion of atty's, the Board's action exceeds their authority.


Imagine the nasty fight that would ensue if Scottish villagers decided in 2015 that the Marquess must rid his "damned hedge of commingling foliage" or cut them to 8 ft. The Marquess would rightly protest. "Well," the villagers might shriek, "our new King can bloody well interpret the law any way he sees fit and, oh by the way, he's siding with us". In that case, the incident would be remarkably similar to what's happening here.    

A more satisfactory solution that would uphold the intent of our covenants would compel a  reasonable attempt at "windowing and trimming" per Building Rule 3.2. The parties themselves could try to resolve disputes with the help of Cape George mediators. 

If no compromise solution arose, an arborist would be hired to specify the extent of limbing that would not endanger the tree's health. All costs would be defrayed evenly between tree owner and complainants. The Cape George Manager would make the final determination of a remedy based on the arborist's report. 

P.S. Here's an example of how effective windowing and thinning can be. This tree used to block half the view of the Dungeness Spit until it was limbed.

  

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

Trees and Views - A Strange Phone Call


A few days ago, I received a call from the party who lodged the most recent Sunset Blvd tree complaint. She launched into a spiel about supporting neighborliness and quickly pointed out she was all for windowing and trimming trees. Finally, she confided many folks didn't seem to have a good opinion of her and hoped we wouldn't "be adversarial". I agreed and the conversation ended.

Her actions however were in stark contrast to her words. She had offered to help the owner pay for remedying the violation but only if ALL THE TREES listed in the "hedge indictment" were cut to the ground. However, she rejected out of hand the owner's compromise offers to fell some trees and window and trim the rest.

Later it occurred to me that she really may support windowing and thinning in theory. But, of course, she needn't be so supportive if an extreme hedge interpretation by a friendly Board could be used to advance her own agenda. And she wasn't.


All that remained to be done was lodge a complaint to coincide with the sale of the property. The owner living in another state would be more likely to cave in and, in any event, would be compelled to remove any such "violation" to finalize a sale. 


The scheme appeared to work perfectly except no one won. Certainly not the residents of Cape George. Instead of resolution, more skirmishes over these issues loom:


 * The out-of-state owner paid a $2000 bill
   for felling trees + fines on her own.   
   This occurred twelve years after the 
   Board voted unanimously in 2003 to dismiss 
   that party's identical complaint against 
   the same trees. Changing a ruling and then 
   applying it retroactively is capricious, 
   heavy-handed, and almost certainly won't 
   survive a court challenge.

 * The Board's extreme prescription for 

   remedying a hedge violation -- "haircut" 
   for shrubs; "death penalty" for trees -- 
   is absurd and  ignores the governing  
   documents' clear language favoring 
   "windowing and thinning" rather than 
   "topping and other forms of tree 
   mutilation".

 * A divisive issue remains and will almost

   certainly be problematic in the future. 
   The Board has disregarded letters from
   multiple attorneys and likely will embroil 
   Cape George in a lawsuit. Several petition 
   signers who opposed the Board have pledged 
   financial assistance should that happen.

 * Views were not improved at all.


The last is particularly significant yet sadly ironic. I stood on streets "impacted" by the trees on the Sunset property before and after the trees were cut. Other trees on the property, not subject to violation, now back-fill the visual gaps left by felled trees. There's no measurable "view" improvement by anyone's standards.


In addition to this needless destruction of property and expense to the owner, the Board acted to champion a "cut-em-all-down" stance in the newsletter while ignoring a compromise to window and thin; they now interpret a hedge to be as little as "two trees with commingling foliage"; and they assert members "voted" affirmatively for this extreme interpretation. In the opinion of many, including the atty's mentioned earlier, the Board's bizarre interpretations and actions are indefensible and overreach their authority.
 

We would like to be saluting the Board for their volunteerism and efforts on behalf of all residents. Instead their actions have been divisive, their statements disingenuous, and their methods arrogant and bullying. To quote our attorney's letter to the Board:   

"However, when the Board attempts to enforce a rule beyond that found in the Covenants in the favor of one member against another, cooperation is not encouraged but rather favor seeking is, and capricious and arbitrary rulings result".

We will continue to oppose the Board's  interpretation of a "hedge" and their actions to promote felling trees instead of windowing and thinning as the governing rules promote.